Modern professional sport is gradually moving beyond the boundaries of purely physical fitness or competitive activities and is becoming an independent sphere of employment. An athlete representing a club, sports organization, school, federation, or another entity engaged in sports activities often performs work not occasionally but on a systematic basis: trains according to an established plan, participates in competitions, complies with internal rules, receives remuneration, and follows the employer’s instructions.
For this reason, employment relations with athletes require a special legal approach. On the one hand, an athlete is an employee and enjoys general employment guarantees, including the right to remuneration, rest, safe working conditions, protection against unlawful dismissal, and compensation for harm. On the other hand, sporting activities have distinctive characteristics: the outcome of an athlete’s work depends on physical fitness, medical condition, eligibility to participate in competitions, discipline, anti-doping control, and sports regulations.
The Labor Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan takes these specific features into account and provides for special rules governing the employment of athletes. This makes it possible to regard an athlete not only as a participant in sports competitions but also as a special subject of labor law.
Legal Nature of Employment Relations with Athletes
Employment relations with an athlete arise where an agreement exists between the athlete and the employer for the athlete to personally perform an employment function for remuneration, subject to the employer’s internal labor rules and with the employer providing appropriate working conditions. In the sports sector, this means that an athlete does not merely participate in competitions but performs a professional employment function in the interests of the employer.
The main criterion distinguishing employment relations from civil-law relations is the athlete’s organizational dependence on the employer. If an athlete is required to follow a training schedule, comply with the instructions of the coaching staff, participate in competitions as directed by the club, use equipment provided by the employer, and comply with the internal sporting regime, such relations are, by their nature, employment relations.
Different contractual models may be used in sports practice, including an employment contract, a civil-law service agreement, an agency agreement, an advertising agreement, and an agreement concerning the transfer or use of an athlete’s image rights. However, where the actual substance of the relationship exhibits the characteristics of an employment relationship, merely designating the agreement as a civil-law contract should not exclude the application of labor legislation.
Athlete as a Special Category of Employee
An athlete constitutes a special category of employee because the athlete’s employment function consists of preparing for sports competitions and participating in such competitions in a particular sport or sports. This is the principal distinctive feature of an athlete’s employment function: it includes not only participation in the competition itself but also the entire preparation process.
An athlete’s preparation includes training activities, recovery, compliance with dietary and rest regimes, medical support, testing, participation in training camps, and implementation of individual preparation plans. Accordingly, an athlete’s work is comprehensive in nature and cannot be reduced merely to the act of appearing in a sporting event.
An athlete’s employer may be a sports club, sports school, sports training center, federation, another physical culture and sports organization, or another entity that employs the athlete in accordance with the established procedure. At the same time, a sports organization is obliged not only to pay remuneration but also to create actual conditions necessary for the athlete to perform his or her sporting employment function.
Contents of an Employment Contract with an Athlete
An employment contract with an athlete must contain the general terms applicable to any employment contract, including the place of work, employment function, remuneration terms, working time and rest arrangements, guarantees, and compensation. However, these terms alone are insufficient for an athlete.
The special provisions of an athlete’s employment contract should address the following matters:
These contractual provisions demonstrate that an athlete’s work is regulated not only by general labor rules but also by sports-related organizational requirements. In this context, the employment contract performs a dual function: it establishes the employment rights and obligations of the parties and provides a legal framework for sporting discipline.
Sporting Regime and Athlete Discipline
The sporting regime is one of the central elements of employment relations with an athlete. It may include requirements concerning training, recovery, nutrition, participation in training camps, compliance with sleep schedules, undergoing medical procedures, prohibition on independently participating in competitions without the employer’s consent, and other rules necessary to achieve sporting results.
From the perspective of labor law, the sporting regime should be regarded as a special form of labor discipline. A violation of the sporting regime may result in disciplinary consequences where the relevant obligations are established by the employment contract, the employer’s internal regulations, or other rules binding upon the athlete.
At the same time, the sporting regime must not violate the athlete’s fundamental employment rights. Under the guise of sporting discipline, the employer may not place the employee in a position less favorable than that prescribed by law, excessively restrict the athlete’s right to rest, or create a threat to the athlete’s life or health.
Medical Examinations, Occupational Safety and Insurance
An athlete’s work is inherently associated with increased physical exertion and the risk of sports-related injuries. For this reason, legislation provides for mandatory preliminary and periodic medical examinations of athletes.
A preliminary medical examination is carried out upon conclusion of the employment contract and is intended to determine the athlete’s fitness to perform the relevant work. Periodic medical examinations are conducted during the term of the employment contract and are intended to monitor the athlete’s state of health and prevent occupational diseases and sports-related injuries.
The employer’s obligation to provide the athlete with sportswear, equipment, sporting implements, and other material and technical resources is of particular importance. This obligation has not only an organizational but also a protective function: the quality of sportswear and equipment directly affects the athlete’s safety and ability to achieve sporting results.
Life and health insurance for an athlete is also an important guarantee. It reflects the increased risks inherent in sporting activities and is intended to protect the athlete in the event of injury, illness, or other adverse consequences associated with the performance of the employment function.
Working Time, Rest and Additional Leave
Sporting activities involve non-standard working time arrangements. Training sessions, training camps, competitions, travel, recovery activities, and medical support may not correspond to the traditional model of a working day. It is therefore advisable for the employment contract and the employer’s internal regulations to clearly define the athlete’s work schedule, the procedure for recording training time, time spent participating in competitions, rest days, and compensation for special working arrangements.
Athletes are entitled to annual additional paid leave. Its duration is determined by collective agreements, internal regulations, or employment contracts but may not be shorter than the minimum established by law. Additional leave serves a recovery function because an athlete’s work involves intensive physical and psychological strain.
Temporary Transfer of an Athlete to Another Employer
One of the most distinctive features of employment relations with athletes is the possibility of a temporary transfer to another employer. This mechanism applies where the original employer is unable to ensure the athlete’s participation in sports competitions.
A temporary transfer is possible subject to an agreement between the employers and the athlete’s written consent. The duration of such a transfer may not exceed one year. During the temporary transfer, the new employer concludes a fixed-term employment contract with the athlete, while the original employment contract is suspended. However, the term of the original contract continues to run.
This model resembles the loan of a player commonly used in international sports practice. From the perspective of labor law, however, it is formalized through a temporary change of employer and the conclusion of a fixed-term employment contract. Its purpose is to balance the interests of all three parties: the athlete receives an opportunity to participate in competitions, the original employer retains its legal relationship with the athlete, and the temporary employer obtains the athlete’s services for a defined period.
Termination of an Employment Contract with an Athlete
An employment contract with an athlete may be terminated on the general grounds established by labor legislation. At the same time, special grounds for termination are provided for athletes.
Such grounds include sporting disqualification for a period of six months or more, as well as a violation by the athlete of anti-doping rules, including a single violation. These grounds arise from the specific nature of sporting activities: where an athlete is unable to participate in competitions or violates fundamental requirements of fair sporting competition, the performance of the athlete’s employment function becomes impossible or materially impaired.
A specific feature of termination of an employment contract at the athlete’s initiative is that the notice period is determined by the parties to the contract, taking into account the periods established by the Ministry of Sports of the Republic of Uzbekistan on the recommendations of sports federations. This makes it possible to take into consideration the specific characteristics of a particular sport, the seasonal nature of competitions, transfer periods, and the interests of the sports team.
Relationship Between Labor and Sports Regulation
An athlete’s work lies at the intersection of labor law and sports law. Labor legislation protects the athlete as an employee, while sports legislation and regulations govern the organization of competitions, eligibility requirements, discipline, the status of sports organizations, and requirements applicable to sporting activities.
This combination of legal rules requires a systematic approach. An employer cannot rely on sports regulations as a means of circumventing employment guarantees. At the same time, an athlete cannot disregard sports regulations if they are incorporated into the employment contract, internal regulations, or are otherwise mandatory in the relevant sport.
In practice, the legal drafting of an employment contract is particularly important. It is necessary to regulate in detail the athlete’s sporting employment function, training regime, procedure for participation in competitions, grounds for payment of bonuses and incentives, medical control rules, procedure for temporary transfer, consequences of disqualification, anti-doping obligations, and dispute resolution procedure.
Problematic Issues and Areas for Improvement
Despite the existence of special regulation, a number of practical issues remain in the field of athlete employment.
First, the distinction between an employment contract and a civil-law agreement with an athlete requires further clarification. Mixed contractual arrangements are frequently used in professional sports, which may result in employment relations being improperly substituted by civil-law relations.
Second, the regulation of performance-based bonuses requires particular attention. In the sports sector, a substantial part of an athlete’s income may depend on results, such as victories, rankings, number of matches played, participation in tournaments, or achievement of established performance standards. Bonus conditions should therefore be transparent, measurable, and supported by documentary evidence.
Third, mechanisms for protecting athletes in the event of injury should be further developed. An injury may temporarily or permanently restrict an athlete’s ability to participate in competitions; therefore, the employment contract should contain clear rules concerning medical support, insurance, payment during periods of temporary incapacity for work, and rehabilitation.
Fourth, regulation of transfers and temporary transfers is an important area. To prevent disputes, the procedure for agreeing upon a transfer, its duration, financial terms, liability of the parties, and consequences of early termination of the temporary contract should be determined in advance.
Fifth, sports organizations should pay greater attention to internal regulations governing the sporting regime, discipline, remuneration, bonuses, sportswear and equipment, medical support, and anti-doping control.
Differences Between Employment Relations with Ordinary Employees and Athletes
|
No. |
Criterion |
Ordinary Employees |
Athletes |
|
1 |
Legal status |
An employee performs an ordinary employment function: administrative, production, technical, managerial, etc. |
An athlete is a special category of employee whose employment function consists of preparing for competitions and participating in them. |
|
2 |
Principal subject matter of work |
Performance of work according to a position, profession, or specialty. |
Sports preparation, training, training camps, and participation in competitions in a particular sport. |
|
3 |
Contents of the employment contract |
Includes general terms: place of work, employment function, remuneration, working arrangements, guarantees, leave, etc. |
In addition to general terms, special provisions are mandatory, including training, participation in competitions, sporting regime, anti-doping rules, and life and health insurance. |
|
4 |
Employer’s obligations |
To provide work, remuneration, safe working conditions, equipment, and other resources necessary for performance of the work. |
Additionally required to provide training activities, participation in competitions, sportswear, sporting equipment, medical examinations, and insurance for the athlete. |
|
5 |
Employee’s obligations |
To perform employment duties conscientiously and comply with internal labor rules, labor discipline, and occupational safety requirements. |
Additionally required to comply with the sporting regime and preparation plans, participate in competitions only as directed by the employer, comply with anti-doping rules, and undergo doping control. |
|
6 |
Medical examinations |
Conducted only in cases prescribed by legislation for particular types of work, professions, or working conditions. |
Preliminary and periodic medical examinations at the employer’s expense are mandatory in order to determine fitness and prevent sports-related injuries. |
|
7 |
Sportswear and equipment |
The employer provides the resources necessary for the ordinary employment function. |
The employer is required, at its own expense, to provide sportswear, equipment, and sporting implements and maintain them in suitable condition. |
|
8 |
Working arrangements |
Usually determined by internal labor rules, work schedules, shift arrangements, and the employment contract. |
Working arrangements are linked to training, training camps, competitions, recovery, and the sports calendar. |
|
9 |
Entitlement to leave |
Minimum annual basic leave is provided under the general rules of the Labor Code. |
In addition to general leave, an athlete is entitled to annual additional paid leave of at least 4 calendar days. |
|
10 |
Participation in employer-organized activities |
The employee performs assigned work within the scope of his or her job duties. |
Participation in competitions forms part of the employment function, but the athlete participates only as directed by the employer. |
|
11 |
Temporary transfer to another employer |
General forms of transfer or secondment are possible under the Labor Code. |
A special temporary transfer of an athlete to another employer is permitted where the original employer is unable to ensure participation in competitions; the athlete’s written consent is required, and the transfer may not exceed one year. |
|
12 |
Contract during a temporary transfer |
As a rule, formalized in accordance with the general rules applicable to changes of employment conditions or transfers. |
During the temporary transfer, the new employer concludes a fixed-term employment contract with the athlete, while the original employment contract is suspended, although its term continues to run. |
|
13 |
Additional grounds for dismissal |
General grounds for termination of an employment contract under the Labor Code and other laws apply. |
In addition, the athlete’s contract may be terminated in the event of sporting disqualification for six months or more, or violation of anti-doping rules, including a single violation. |
|
14 |
Notice period for termination at the employee’s initiative |
Determined under the general rules of the Labor Code. |
For an athlete, the notice period is determined by the parties taking into account the periods established by the Ministry of Sports upon recommendations of sports federations. |
|
15 |
Role of internal regulations |
Internal regulations govern internal work rules, remuneration, bonuses, discipline, and other matters. |
Internal regulations have increased significance and may govern the sporting regime, preparation plans, performance bonuses, sportswear and equipment, medical support, and discipline. |
|
16 |
Nature of risks |
Risks are usually associated with production, organizational, or professional working conditions. |
Risks include sports-related injuries, loss of eligibility to participate in competitions, disqualification, violation of anti-doping rules, and inability to participate in the sporting season. |