The acquisition of interests in the charter capital of a limited liability company (LLC) is one of the most common methods of investment, changing the composition of the company’s participants, and establishing corporate control.
From the standpoint of corporate law, such a transaction results in the transfer to the acquirer of a set of rights associated with participation in the company. These include the right to participate in the management of the company, vote at the general meeting of participants, receive a portion of distributed profits, and claim a portion of the company’s assets upon its liquidation.
However, the acquisition of a significant interest in an LLC may have consequences not only for corporate relations within the company but also for the state of competition in the relevant commodity or financial market. In certain cases, such a transaction results in the concentration of corporate control, consolidation of economic resources, and strengthening of the market position of a particular person or group of persons.
Therefore, the legislation of the Republic of Uzbekistan provides for preliminary state control over certain transactions involving the acquisition of interests in limited liability companies. The principal special regulatory act in this area is the Regulation on the Procedure for Obtaining Preliminary Consent for Economic Concentration, approved by Resolution No. 256 of the Cabinet of Ministers of the Republic of Uzbekistan dated May 1, 2024.
Concept of Economic Concentration in Relation to an LLC
Economic concentration means the conclusion of transactions or performance of other actions that result in the predominance of a business entity or a group of persons and affect the state of competition in a commodity or financial market. In relation to a limited liability company, economic concentration primarily takes the form of the acquisition by a person or group of persons of a significant interest in the charter capital of the company.
At the same time, economic concentration is not limited exclusively to the formal transfer of ownership of an interest. The economic result of the transaction is also relevant, including:
Accordingly, when conducting a legal assessment of a transaction, it is necessary to consider not only the size of the interest being acquired but also the corporate, economic, and competitive consequences of its acquisition.
Acquisition of More Than One-Third of Interests as a Form of Economic Concentration
State control over economic concentration applies where a person or group of persons acquires the right to dispose of more than one-third of the interests in the charter capital of an LLC. Thus, the formal corporate threshold is the acquisition of an interest exceeding one-third of the company’s charter capital.
This criterion means that the acquisition of exactly one-third of the interests does not, in itself, meet the threshold established by the Regulation. The obligation to obtain preliminary consent arises where the acquired interest exceeds one-third.
The threshold is determined not only by reference to a specific transaction but also taking into account interests already held by the acquirer. For example, if a person owns 20 percent of the interests in an LLC and acquires an additional 15 percent, its aggregate interest will amount to 35 percent. In such a case, the corporate threshold will be exceeded.
Similarly, interests held by other persons belonging to the same group of persons as the acquirer must also be taken into account. Therefore, splitting interests among affiliated companies or individuals does not exclude the application of economic concentration rules.
Concept of Acquisition of the Right to Dispose of Interests
For the purposes of antimonopoly control, not only the formal acquisition of ownership of an interest is relevant, but also the acquisition of the right to dispose of the relevant interest. Such right may arise on the basis of:
Accordingly, when determining whether preliminary consent is required, the actual structure of the transaction must be analyzed. The formal name of the agreement is not decisive if its result is the transfer of control over more than one-third of the interests in an LLC.
Financial Criteria for Mandatory Approval
Exceeding the corporate threshold of one-third does not always automatically give rise to an obligation to obtain preliminary consent from the antimonopoly authority. At least one of the prescribed financial conditions must also be met.
Preliminary consent is required if:
Thus, the requirement for approval is determined by applying two groups of criteria simultaneously:
If the corporate threshold is exceeded but the financial indicators do not reach the prescribed values, preliminary consent is generally not required. However, the assessment must be conducted not only with respect to the direct acquirer but also taking into account the composition of the group of persons to which it belongs.
Investor and Parties to the Transaction
An investor is an individual, legal entity, or group of persons acquiring interests in the charter capital of a business entity in its own name and at its own expense. The parties to the transaction include:
For the purposes of antimonopoly analysis, not only the activities of the investor itself are examined, but also the activities of persons controlled by it or persons controlling it. This is particularly important where the acquirer is:
The antimonopoly authority assesses the entire economic group rather than only the formal acquirer of the interest.
Significance of a Group of Persons in the Acquisition of Interests in an LLC
A group of persons is a combination of individuals and legal entities having a common economic interest and meeting the statutory criteria for interconnection. The concept of a group of persons is intended to prevent circumvention of antimonopoly requirements by distributing corporate participation among interdependent entities. When calculating the amount of interests being acquired, the following may be taken into account:
For example, if one company within a group owns 20 percent of the interests in an LLC and another company within the same group acquires an additional 20 percent, the aggregate participation of the group will amount to 40 percent. In such a case, the threshold of more than one-third will be exceeded.
The antimonopoly authority may request information regarding the ownership structure, composition of participants, corporate control, and the investor’s participation in other business entities.
Ultimate Beneficial Owners
When filing an application, the parties to the transaction are required to provide information regarding individuals who effectively control legal entities through direct or indirect ownership of more than 25 percent of the interests. Such persons are regarded as principal beneficial owners.
Disclosure of beneficial owners enables the antimonopoly authority to determine:
Disclosure of the beneficial ownership structure is particularly important in cross-border transactions where the direct investor may be incorporated in a foreign jurisdiction and may constitute an intermediate holding company.
Exceptions for Certain Transactions Involving Interests in an LLC
The Regulation provides for a number of cases in which its requirements do not apply. With respect to transactions involving LLCs, the following exceptions apply in particular.
1. Acquisition of Interests by Founders upon Establishment of the Company
The allocation of interests among founders at the time of establishment of an LLC is not regarded as a transaction requiring preliminary consent under the economic concentration procedure. This is because the company is only being established and there is no pre-existing independent business entity over which control is being transferred to another person.
2. Acquisition by the Company of Its Own Interests
The preliminary consent requirements do not apply to the acquisition by an LLC of interests in its own charter capital. However, any subsequent distribution or transfer of such an interest to a third party must be assessed separately.
3. Reorganization of an LLC by Transformation
The requirements do not apply where the company is transformed into another legal form, provided that the amount of the charter capital remains unchanged. In this case, the legal form changes, but the control structure does not necessarily change.
4. Acquisition of Interests by an Individual
The Regulation provides for an exception for the acquisition of interests by an individual where, at the time of application, such individual does not have the right to dispose of more than 25 percent of the interests in any business entity.
This exception requires careful application. It is necessary to take into account not only the individual’s direct ownership but also his or her possible participation in a group of persons and indirect control over legal entities.
Timing for Obtaining Preliminary Consent
The application must be submitted before completion of the transaction involving the acquisition of interests. This means that the parties may not complete the transfer of the interest before obtaining a decision from the antimonopoly authority if the transaction meets the corporate and financial criteria for economic concentration.
In practice, it is advisable to include a preliminary approval condition directly in the interest purchase agreement. The agreement may provide that:
Such a structure reduces the risk of the transaction being deemed completed before mandatory consent has been obtained.
Authority Reviewing the Application
Jurisdiction to review the application depends on the geographical scope of the parties’ activities and the status of the investor. The central office of the Committee for the Development of Competition and Consumer Protection reviews the application if:
A territorial body of the Committee reviews the application where all parties conduct activities within a single region. Accordingly, the acquisition of an interest in an Uzbek LLC by a foreign company or foreign citizen falls within the competence of the central antimonopoly authority.
Procedure for Applying for Preliminary Consent
The application is submitted electronically through a Public Services Center or the Unified Portal of Interactive Public Services. The applicant may be one of the parties to the transaction or its representative whose authority is confirmed by an appropriate document.
The application must be accompanied by:
For a non-resident legal entity, a copy of its state registration document or equivalent document must be provided. For a foreign individual, a copy of the passport must be provided.
Financial statements in a foreign language must be officially translated into the state language and notarized. At the same time, the applicant may not be required to provide information and documents that are not expressly provided for by the Regulation.
Financial and Business Information
The parties to the transaction must provide information regarding their activities for the two years preceding the filing of the application. If the activities have been conducted for less than two years, the information must be provided for the actual period of operations. The following must be disclosed:
Such information is necessary to determine whether the investor and the LLC being acquired operate:
Review of the Application
The application is reviewed by a special commission of the antimonopoly authority. If the transaction does not affect competition, a decision must be made no later than 30 calendar days from the date of receipt of the necessary documents and information. If the acquisition of interests may result in restriction of competition, the review period may be extended for additional analysis, but for no more than two months.
When reviewing the transaction, the antimonopoly authority assesses:
Grounds for Refusal
The antimonopoly authority refuses to grant preliminary consent if:
Refusal on other grounds in the course of reviewing transactions involving the acquisition of interests is not permitted. Accordingly, a refusal must be based either on the competitive consequences of the transaction or on the unreliability of the information submitted by the applicant.
Possibility of Approving a Transaction Where Consumer Benefits Exist
Even where the acquisition of an interest may strengthen a dominant position or restrict competition, the transaction may be approved if the parties demonstrate that it will provide substantial benefits to consumers.
Such benefits may include:
The benefits must be specific and capable of substantiation.
A general statement that the transaction constitutes an investment or contributes to business development is insufficient. The applicant must substantiate the connection between the acquisition of the interest and the anticipated benefits for consumers.
Conditional Consent and Remedial Measures
The antimonopoly authority may grant consent subject to compliance with requirements aimed at preserving competition. Such requirements may be structural or behavioral in nature.
Fee for Granting Consent
Upon filing the application, an initial fee equal to one Basic Calculation Value (BCV) is payable. After a decision approving the transaction is adopted, the final amount of the fee is calculated. For the acquisition of interests by a resident legal entity, the fee is calculated at 0.05 percent of the aggregate revenue of the parties to the transaction for the preceding calendar year.
Where there is no revenue, the calculation is based on the aggregate book value of assets. The minimum fee is 7 BCV and the maximum fee is 1,000 BCV. A special calculation procedure applies to foreign investors, taking into account their financial statements and the exchange rate of the Central Bank. The remaining portion of the fee must be paid within 30 calendar days after the relevant notification is sent. If the fee is not paid within the prescribed period, the decision granting preliminary consent is cancelled.
Validity Period of the Consent
The transaction involving the acquisition of an interest must be completed within 1 (one) year from the date of the decision granting preliminary consent. If the transfer of the interest is not completed within this period, the decision ceases to be valid.
In order to subsequently complete the transaction, a new application for approval must be submitted. Therefore, when planning the transaction, it is necessary to take into account:
Inheritance and Legal Succession
A special notification procedure applies to unilateral transactions or legal events involving inheritance and legal succession. If, as a result of inheritance or legal succession, a person acquires the right to dispose of an interest exceeding the prescribed threshold, that person must notify the antimonopoly authority within 15 calendar days from the date on which the relevant right arises.
The notification must specify:
Thus, in such cases, subsequent notification rather than preliminary approval applies.
Consequences of Acquiring an Interest Without Preliminary Consent
If a participant acquires more than one-third of the interests in an LLC without obtaining mandatory preliminary consent, the antimonopoly authority initiates proceedings for violation of competition legislation.
Following consideration of the case, a special commission may decide:
Irrespective of the decision adopted, a fine may be imposed on the violator for completing the transaction without preliminary consent. If the transaction has resulted in restriction of competition, it may be declared invalid by a court upon a claim filed by the antimonopoly authority.
As a result, the parties may be required to: