A pledge is one of the oldest and most effective forms of securing the performance of obligations. In a market economy, it acquires particular importance as it guarantees creditors the return of the funds provided or the fulfillment of other obligations. The Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On Pledge” (as amended on May 1, 1998) regulates the procedure for establishing, types, and legal consequences of a pledge.
According to Article 1 of the Law, a pledge is the transfer of property or property rights by one person to another to secure obligations. In case the debtor fails to perform the obligation, the creditor has the right to satisfy his claims at the expense of the pledged property in a preferential order.
A pledge may arise based on a contract or by operation of law, as provided in Article 3. The Law defines both general provisions on pledges and their specific types.
The legislation of Uzbekistan provides for several types of pledges, each with its own characteristics.
1. Pawn (Zaklad)
A pawn is a type of pledge in which property is transferred into the possession of the creditor (pledgee). The distinctive feature is that the creditor physically controls the pledged item, minimizing the risk of its loss or alienation.
Example: Pawnshop operations, where items are transferred as security for short-term loans.
Features: The pledgee is responsible for the safekeeping of the property and may use it only within the limits of the agreement.
2. Mortgage (Ipoteka)
A mortgage is a pledge of immovable property that remains in the possession of the pledgor. It is used to secure major obligations (bank loans, investment projects).
Subject: Buildings, structures, apartments, land plots (within the limits allowed by law).
Difference: The property is not transferred to the creditor but must be registered with the state.
3. Pledge of Rights and Property Claims
A pledge may be established not only on things but also on property rights.
Subject: Lease rights, claims against debtors, exclusive rights.
Feature: In case of default, the creditor may acquire these rights and use them to satisfy his claims.
4. Pledge of Securities
A separate type of pledge is the pledge of securities, as provided in Article 45 of the Law.
Subject: Shares, bonds, and other securities.
Features: Securities may be transferred to the creditor or deposited with a notary office. Unless otherwise agreed, income from the securities belongs to the pledgor.
5. Pledge of Goods in Circulation
The law also provides for a specific type – the pledge of goods in circulation.
Subject: Raw materials, materials, goods in stock, and trade turnover.
Feature: The composition and volume of the pledged items may change, but their total value must not fall below the amount specified in the contract.
Legal Significance of the Classification of Pledges
The classification of pledges has important practical significance:
Thus, the legislation of Uzbekistan provides for several main types of pledges: pawn, mortgage, pledge of property rights, pledge of securities, and pledge of goods in circulation. Each has its own specifics related to the subject of the pledge, the manner of its transfer, and the enforcement process. This system ensures a balance of interests between creditors and debtors and the stability of civil transactions.
Comparative Table of Types of Pledge
|
Type of Pledge |
Subject of Pledge |
Formalization Procedure |
Features |
Advantages |
Disadvantages |
|
Pawn |
Movable property (items, valuables) transferred to the creditor |
Written agreement, physical transfer to the creditor; in pawnshops – issuance of a pawn ticket |
The pledged item is in the creditor’s possession, who must store and insure it |
Minimal risk of loss by debtor; high creditor protection |
Limits debtor’s use of property; risk of damage while in creditor’s possession |
|
Mortgage |
Immovable property: buildings, structures, apartments, vehicles, land (within the law) |
Written, notarized agreement with mandatory state registration |
Property remains with the debtor; creditor has right of enforcement upon default |
Debtor continues to use property; creditor protection via registry |
Complicated registration procedure; risk of property value decline |
|
Pledge of Property Rights |
Lease rights, claims, other property rights |
Written agreement; sometimes notarized |
The subject is not a thing but a right; creditor may obtain the claim |
Flexibility: allows pledging intangible assets |
Difficult valuation and enforcement; potential third-party disputes |
|
Pledge of Securities |
Shares, bonds, etc. |
Written agreement; securities transferred to creditor or notary deposit |
Income from securities usually belongs to debtor |
High liquidity; easy sale via stock exchange |
Market value fluctuations; limited availability of securities |
|
Pledge of Goods in Circulation |
Raw materials, materials, finished goods, inventories |
Written agreement; property remains with debtor |
Composition may change, but total value must remain stable |
Convenient for entrepreneurs; maintains business turnover |
Hard to control inventory; risk of debtor’s bad faith actions |
Procedure for Formalizing a Pledge
|
Type of Pledge |
Form of Agreement |
Additional Requirements |
Actions of the Parties |
|
Pawn |
Written agreement; sometimes notarized |
Physical transfer of property to the creditor |
Creditor accepts, insures, and stores property; debtor loses possession |
|
Mortgage (Real Estate) |
Written and notarized agreement |
State registration with the real estate registry |
Property remains with debtor but is encumbered; without registration, mortgage is invalid |
|
Pledge of Property Rights |
Written agreement; sometimes notarized |
Notification of the debtor (third party) whose obligation is pledged |
Upon default, creditor acquires or enforces the claim through court |
|
Pledge of Securities |
Written agreement; sometimes notarized |
Transfer to creditor or notary; entry in shareholder/depository register (for registered securities) |
Securities held by creditor or notary; income usually belongs to debtor |
|
Pledge of Goods in Circulation |
Written agreement |
Must state total value and maintain it at contractual level |
Goods’ composition may vary, but total value must remain unchanged |