The institution of copyright and related (neighboring) rights is one of the key components of the legal regulation of intellectual property. It ensures the protection of the results of creative activity, stimulates cultural and scientific development of society, and establishes legal mechanisms for the fair distribution of income derived from the use of works.
In the Republic of Uzbekistan, the basic regulatory act in this field is the Law “On Copyright and Related Rights,” which lays down the fundamental provisions of the legal regime for the protection of works of science, literature, and art, as well as the results of performing and broadcasting activities.
The purpose of the Law is to regulate relations arising in connection with the creation and use of works of science, literature, and art, as well as objects of related rights. Thus, the legislator emphasizes the comprehensive nature of legal regulation, covering both the creative result itself and the process of its commercial and non-commercial exploitation.
An important principle is the priority of international treaties of the Republic of Uzbekistan over national legislation, which ensures the harmonization of the domestic legal system with international standards in the field of intellectual property.
Article 3 of the Law contains an extensive conceptual framework, including definitions of such key categories as “work,” “publication,” “reproduction,” “performance,” “phonogram,” “making available to the public,” and others. Their normative consolidation is of fundamental importance for law-enforcement practice, since it is precisely through these concepts that the content of exclusive rights and the scope of permissible use of copyright objects are revealed.
Scope and Objects of Copyright
Copyright applies to works of science, literature, and art that are the result of creative activity and are expressed in an objective form, regardless of their purpose, merit, or method of expression. At the same time, it is the form of expression of a work that is protected, rather than ideas, methods, or concepts as such, which corresponds to the classical doctrine of copyright law.
The Law provides a detailed list of protected works, including literary, musical, and audiovisual works, computer programs, databases, and derivative works. At the same time, it establishes a list of objects that are not subject to copyright protection (official documents, state symbols, and works of folklore).
Emergence of Copyright and the Presumption of Authorship
A significant feature of Uzbek legislation is the provision that copyright arises by virtue of the fact of creation of a work and does not require registration or compliance with any formalities. The presumption of authorship ensures protection of the author’s rights at the very initial stage of the existence of a work, which is particularly important in the digital environment.
Moral (Non-Property) and Economic (Property) Rights of the Author
The author holds moral (non-property) rights, including the right of authorship, the right to a name, the right of publication, and the right to protection of reputation. These rights are inalienable and are protected indefinitely.
The author’s economic rights are exclusive in nature and include the right of reproduction, distribution, making available to the public, public performance, translation, and adaptation of the work. It is these rights that constitute the economic foundation of copyright and may be transferred under a copyright agreement.
Concept and Subjects of Related Rights
Related rights are aimed at protecting the interests of persons who do not create the work but ensure its communication to the public. The subjects of related rights include performers, producers of phonograms, and broadcasting organizations (terrestrial or cable).
The emergence of related rights, like copyright, does not require registration, which simplifies the mechanism for their exercise and protection.
Content and Limits of Related Rights
Performers hold rights to be identified by name, to protection of their performance, and exclusive economic rights. Producers of phonograms and broadcasting organizations possess exclusive rights to use the respective objects, including reproduction, distribution, and broadcasting.
Related rights have a limited term of protection (as a rule, 50 years), which reflects their auxiliary nature in relation to copyright and ensures a balance between the interests of right holders and society.
General Assessment
An analysis of the Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan “On Copyright and Related Rights” leads to the conclusion that the national model of copyright protection is systematic and conceptually well-structured. The Law consistently distinguishes between copyright and related rights, establishes a broad range of protected objects, and provides effective mechanisms for the protection of the rights of right holders.
At the same time, issues related to the adaptation of these norms to the digital environment require further scholarly consideration, in particular the use of works on the Internet and the cross-border circulation of intellectual property objects.
Differences Between Copyright and Related Rights
|
Criterion |
Copyright |
Related Rights |
|
Legal nature |
Protects the result of creative activity (works of science, literature, and art) |
Protects the result of performing, organizational, and technical activity related to making a work available to the public |
|
Legal basis |
Chapter 2 of the Law “On Copyright and Related Rights” |
Chapter 3 of the Law “On Copyright and Related Rights” |
|
Object of protection |
Works of science, literature, and art in any objective form |
Performances, phonograms, broadcasts of broadcasting organizations |
|
Creative element |
Mandatory |
May be absent |
|
Subjects |
Author (individual), co-authors, heirs, other right holders |
Performers, phonogram producers, broadcasting organizations |
|
Moment of emergence |
From the moment of creation, without registration |
From the moment of performance, recording, or broadcast, without registration |
|
Registration requirement |
Not required |
Not required |
|
Moral rights |
Present |
Limited (mainly for performers) |
|
Alienability of moral rights |
Inalienable |
Inalienable (for performers) |
|
Economic rights |
Reproduction, distribution, making available, translation, adaptation, public performance, rental, etc. |
Reproduction, distribution, making available, broadcasting, rental, retransmission |
|
Right to remuneration |
For each method of use |
For use of performance, phonogram, or broadcast |
|
Transfer by contract |
Under copyright agreements |
By agreement, copyright rules applied by analogy |
|
Term of protection |
Life of the author + 70 years |
50 years |
|
Public domain |
After expiration of protection |
Same |
|
Protection symbol |
© name of right holder, year |
℗ name of right holder, year |
|
Relationship |
Primary right |
Derivative right |
|
Dependence |
Independent |
Must not infringe copyright |
Limitations of Copyright
|
Type of limitation |
Legal regime |
Conditions |
Consent required |
Remuneration |
Practical comment |
|
General principle |
Only as provided by law |
No unjustified harm |
No |
No |
Implements the “three-step test” |
|
Private copying |
Personal use copying |
With exclusions |
No |
No |
Must not become hidden distribution |
|
Free use with attribution |
Quotation, education, reviews |
Attribution required |
No |
No |
Key for science and media |
|
Reprographic copying |
Libraries and archives |
Limited copies |
No |
No |
Prevents mass copying |
|
Works in public places |
Architecture, sculpture |
Non-commercial |
No |
No |
Limited freedom of panorama |
|
Ceremonial use |
Official and religious ceremonies |
Proportional |
No |
No |
Socially oriented |
|
Judicial use |
Court proceedings |
Procedural necessity |
No |
No |
Important for evidence |
|
Temporary recording |
By broadcasters |
Destroyed after 6 months |
No |
No |
Technical exception |
|
Software & databases |
Use by lawful owner |
Functional use |
No |
No |
Linked to functionality |
|
Levy for private copying |
Phonograms and AV works |
Via importers |
No |
Yes |
Collective compensation mechanism |
Copyright and related rights form a unified but heterogeneous system of intellectual property protection. Copyright has a primary and creative character, while related rights perform an auxiliary function, ensuring the economic and organizational exploitation of works. Their distinction is of fundamental importance for the correct legal qualification of relations, determination of the scope of rights, and selection of appropriate remedies for the protection of infringed rights.